Misinformation (false information shared without prior intent to publish and without harming others), and disinformation (false information shared with prior intent to publish and aimed at harming others).
When selecting a topic related to fact-checking, we adhere to the following criteria:
- The content must include misleading information such as: fabricated images, manipulated videos, images taken out of context, videos taken out of context, or content containing false news.
- The content, or at least one of its elements, must be verifiable.
- The fact-check should be relevant to the Egyptian or broader Arab audience.
- The content should be recent or still have an ongoing impact.
- The content should concern a large segment of the public and/or be widely circulated and influential.
- The fact-checking process should serve the public interest and not favor one party over another.
- The claim has not already been denied by the targeted party, or a large segment of the audience still believes it and it continues to have an impact.
Fact-Checking Methodology:
1. Verifying the Claim
- What is the claim?
- What is its classification?
Claim classifications:
- False: The claim is entirely incorrect.
- Partly False: The claim contains both correct and incorrect elements.
- Fabricated: The event or claim never happened (e.g., falsely attributed quotes to a public figure).
- Misleading (Out of Context): The information is originally correct but has been manipulated, such as being taken out of context or presented with a misleading headline.
- Satirical: The publisher intentionally altered facts for humor, but some audiences interpreted it as real news. This may come from known satire sources or not.
- True: The claim is verified as accurate.
How do we identify misinformation?
- Refer back to official sources
- Use image and video verification tools
- Rely on expert and specialist opinions
- Use open-source information and relevant local, regional, and international databases
2. Content Reach and Impact
- The extent of content spread (engagement numbers, number of pages sharing it)
- Its impact on the audience (positive or negative reactions)
3. Coordinated Campaigns Behind the Content
- Who initiated the misleading content? (profile of the individual or entity)
- Is it part of a larger campaign? Is there a hashtag associated with it?
- Is there interaction from automated (bot) accounts?
- Is the activity around hashtags sudden or unusual?
- What type of engagement exists? (manufactured content, repeated/copied content, replies, resharing)